Mitigating Human-Elephant Conflict in Southeast Asia

Poldej Kochprapa; Chution Savini; Dusit Ngoprasert; Tommaso Savini; George Gale

doi:10.58837/tnh.24.1.262158

Authors

Poldej Kochprapa Conservation Ecology Program, School of Bioresources & Technology, King Mongkut's University of Technology, 49 Soi Tientalay 25, Bangkhuntien-Chaitalay Road, Thakham, Bangkhuntien, Bangkok 10150, THAILAND
Chution Savini Department of Hospitality and Tourism Management, International College of Sustainability Studies (SWUIC), Srinakharinwirot University, 114 Sukumvit 23 Bangkok 10110 THAILAND
Dusit Ngoprasert Conservation Ecology Program, School of Bioresources & Technology, King Mongkut's University of Technology, 49 Soi Tientalay 25, Bangkhuntien-Chaitalay Road, Thakham, Bangkhuntien, Bangkok 10150, THAILAND
Tommaso Savini Conservation Ecology Program, School of Bioresources & Technology, King Mongkut's University of Technology, 49 Soi Tientalay 25, Bangkhuntien-Chaitalay Road, Thakham, Bangkhuntien, Bangkok 10150, THAILAND
George Gale Conservation Ecology Program, School of Bioresources & Technology, King Mongkut's University of Technology, 49 Soi Tientalay 25, Bangkhuntien-Chaitalay Road, Thakham, Bangkhuntien, Bangkok 10150, THAILAND

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.58837/tnh.24.1.262158

Keywords:

crop damage, decision making, human-elephant conflict, mitigation measures, Southeast Asia

Abstract

Human-elephant conflict (HEC) poses serious threats to humans and to elephants, and while HEC in Southeast Asia is increasing, mitigation effectiveness data are lacking. Previous assessments of available mitigation options have not compared relative benefits and impacts of each on a practical level to identify which factors should be considered by local agricultural communities and/or other stakeholders when choosing among mitigation options. Understanding which mitigation approach to apply in a given context is crucial for effective mitigation planning and can aid in the development of more holistic methods. We reviewed the literature regarding the strengths and weaknesses of 14 currently applied HEC mitigation methods in Southeast Asia, considering five key factors for each mitigation option: 1) effectiveness at reducing crop damage, 2) initial start-up costs, 3) maintenance/long-term costs, 4) potential impacts on humans and 5) potential impacts on elephants. Our results suggest there are considerable tradeoffs among these five factors for any given mitigation option and that none of the available mitigation methods are simultaneously highly effective in preventing crop damage and low cost while presenting minimal impact to people and elephants. Although our metric of comparison is not comprehensive, it may offer an initial set of guidelines for decision making.

References

Allendorf, T., Swe, K. K., Aung, M., Leimgruber, P., and Songer, M. 2015. Mitigating human-elephant conflict near Shwe-U-Daung wildlife Sanctuary, Myanmar. Gajah, 42: 22â.

Andyono, G., Marsono, D., Sadono, R., and Imron, M. A. 2018. The analysis on the stakeholders of conflict mitigation in the way Kambas National Park, Lampung. KINERJA, 22: 15–28.

Anthony, B., Scott, P., and Antypas, A. 2010. Sitting on the fence? policies and practices in managing human-wildlife conflict in Limpopo Province, South Africa. Conservation and Society, 8: 225.

Asimopoulos, S. 2016. Human-wildlife conflict mitigation in Peninsular Malaysia: Lessons learnt, current views and Future Directions. SLU/Dept. of Urban and Rural Development.

Branco, P. S., Merkle, J. A., Pringle, R. M., Pansu, J., Potter, A. B., Reynolds, A., Stalmans, M., and Long, R. A. 2019. Determinants of elephant foraging behaviour in a coupled human‐natural system: Is Brown the new green? Journal of Animal Ecology, 88(5): 780–792.

Branco P. S., Merkle J. A., and Pringle R. M. 2020. An experimental test of community-based strategies for mitigating human–wildlife conflict around protected areas. Conservation Letters. 13.

Budd, K., Suddychan, D., Tyson, M., Coudrat, C. N., McWilliam, A., Hallam, C. D., Johnson, A., and Eggert, L. S. 2023. Effects of a hydropower project on a high‐value Asian elephant population. Ecology and Evolution, 13(7).

Butler, K. M., Griffin, A., Herath, S., King, L., and Moltchaniswkyj, N. 2019. Behaviour and crop-raiding patterns of Asian elephants (Elephas Maximus): Can beehive fences help mitigate human-elephant conflict in Sri Lanka?. NOVA. https://nova.newcastle.edu.au/vital/access/manager/Repository/uon:36922

Chan, A. N., Wittemyer, G., McEvoy, J., Williams, A. C., Cox, N., Soe, P., Grindley, M., Shwe, N. M., Chit, A. M., Oo, Z. M., and Leimgruber, P. 2022. Landscape characteristics influence ranging behavior of Asian elephants at the human-wildlands interface in Myanmar. Movement Ecology, 10(1).

Chang’a, A., Souza de, N., Muya, J., Keyyu, J., Mwakatobe, A., Malugu, L., Ndossi, H. P., Konuche, J., Omondi, R., Mpinge, A., Hahn, N., Palminteri, S., and Olson, D. 2016. Scaling-up the use of chili fences for reducing human-elephant conflict across landscapes in Tanzania. Tropical Conservation Science, 9(2): 921–930.

Chartier, L., Zimmermann, A., and Ladle, R. J. 2011. Habitat loss and human–elephant conflict in Assam, India: does a critical threshold exist?. Oryx, 45(4): 528-533.

Chiyo, P. I., Lee, P. C., Moss, C. J., Archie, E. A., Hollister-Smith, J. A., and Alberts, S. C. 2011. No risk, no gain: Effects of crop raiding and genetic diversity on body size in male elephants. Behavioral Ecology, 22(3): 552–558.

Das, G., Selvan, K., Lahkar, B., and Gopi, G. V. 2022. Effectiveness of physical barriers in mitigating human–elephant negative interactions in north-East India. Frontiers in Conservation Science, 3.

de Silva, S., and Srinivasan, K. 2019. Revisiting social natures: People-Elephant Conflict and coexistence in Sri Lanka. Geoforum, 102: 182–190.

Denninger Snyder, K., and Rentsch, D. 2020. Rethinking assessment of success of mitigation strategies for elephant‐induced crop damage. Conservation Biology, 34(4): 829–842.

Desai, A. A., and Riddle, H. S. 2015. Human-elephant conflict in Asia. Supported by: US Fish and Wildlife Service Asian Elephant Support.

Diana, C. E., Abdullah, A., Efendi, E., Supriatno, S., Hambal, M., and Andayani, K. 2021. Risk level analysis of human-elephant in the Peusangan watershed of Aceh Province, Indonesia. IOP Conference Series: Earth and Environmental Science, 922(1), 012052.

Dror, S., Harich, F., Duangphakdee, O., Savini, T., Pogány, Á., Roberts, J., Geheran, J., and Treydte, A. C. 2020. Are Asian elephants afraid of honeybees? experimental studies in Northern Thailand. Mammalian Biology, 100(4): 355–363.

English, M., and Collins, G. S. 2022. The Elephant in the Garden: Bunong Chamkars and Human-Elephant Conflict in Andoung Kraloeng, Cambodia. Gajah, 55.

Enukwa, E. H. 2017. Human-Elephant conflict mitigation methods: A review of effectiveness and sustainability. Journal of Wildlife and Biodiversity, 1(2): 69–78.

Fernando, P. 2008. Review of human-elephant conflict mitigation measures practiced in South Asia. WWF.

Fernando, P., P. Leimgruber, T. Prasad, and J. Pastorini. 2012. Problem-Elephant Translocation: Translocating the Problem and the Elephant? PLOS ONE 7(12):e50917.

Fernando, S. and Matsuda, H. 2020. Human-elephant conflict in Dimbulagala, Sri Lanka: causes and solutions. Yokohama National University.

Gallagher, F. V. 2012. Elephant Over-population: Towards a Theory of a Just Cull. Doctoral dissertation, University of the Witwatersrand, Faculty of Humanities, School of Social Sciences.

Ghani, N. A. A. 2019. Developing an evidence-based policy and protocol for human-elephant conflict in oil palm plantations. University of Nottingham, Malaysia Campus. 96 pp.

Gross, E. M., Lahkar, B. P., Subedi, N., Nyirenda, V. R., Lichtenfeld, L. L., and Jakoby, O. 2019. Does traditional and advanced guarding reduce crop losses due to wildlife? A comparative analysis from Africa and Asia. Journal for Nature Conservation, 50: 125712.

Gubbi, S., Swaminath, M. H., Poornesha, H. C., Bhat, R., and Raghunath, R. 2014. An elephantine challenge: human–elephant conflict distribution in the largest Asian elephant population, southern India. Biodiversity and conservation, 23(3): 633-647.

Gunaryadi D, Sugiyo, and Hedges, S. 2017. Community-based human–elephant conflict mitigation: The value of an evidence-based approach in promoting the uptake of effective methods. PLoS ONE 12(5): e0173742.

Hoare, R. 2015. Lessons from 20 years of human–elephant conflict mitigation in Africa. Human Dimensions of Wildlife, 20(4): 289-295.

HUTAN. 2020. Elephants. Available from: https://www.hutan.org.my/our-work/elephants/

IUCN. 2020. Guidelines for conserving connectivity through ecological networks and corridors. IUCN.

Jarungrattanapong, R. 2012. Exploring the concept of payment for environmental services to help mitigate human-elephant conflict in Thailand. Ritsumeikan Asia Pacific University. 227 pp.

Kalam, T., Kumar Baishya, H., and Smith, D. 2018. Lethal fence electrocution: A major threat to Asian elephants in Assam, India. Tropical Conservation Science, 11.

Khounboline, K., Sisomphane, C., Norachak, B., Ledecq, T., Johnson, A., and Salter, R. 2003. Getting along with the neighbors: human elephant relationships in Lao PDR and the potential for conflict resolution. Tiger Paper, 31: 106-110.

King, L. E., Douglas-Hamilton, I., and Vollrath, F. 2011. Beehive fences as effective deterrents for crop-raiding elephants: Field trials in Northern Kenya. African Journal of Ecology, 49(4): 431–439.

King, L. E., Lala, F., Nzumu, H., Mwambingu, E., and Douglas‐Hamilton, I. 2017. Beehive fences as a multidimensional conflict‐mitigation tool for farmers coexisting with elephants. Conservation Biology, 31(4): 743–752.

Kitratporn, N., and Takeuchi, W. 2019. Spatiotemporal distribution of human–elephant conflict in eastern Thailand: A model-based assessment using news reports and remotely sensed data. Remote Sensing, 12(1): 90.

Kochprapa, P., Savini, C., Ngoprasert, D., Savini, T., and Gale, G. A. 2023. Spatio‐temporal dynamics of human−elephant conflict in a valley of pineapple plantations. Integrative Conservation, 2(2): 95–107.

Kroutnoi, L., Sriburi, T., Wijitkosum, S., and Nuanyai, K. 2018. Determination of stimulating factors of wild Asian elephant (Elephas maximus) dispersal from the Kaeng Krachan National Park to surrounding land use in Thailand. Walailak Journal of Science and Technology (WJST), 17(4): 392–404.

Kuswanda, W., Garsetiasih, R., Gunawan, H., Situmorang, R. O., Hutapea, F. J., Kwatrina, R. T., Karlina, E., Atmoko, T., Zahrah, M., Takandjandji, M., and Gunaryadi, D. 2022. Can humans and elephants coexist? A review of the conflict on Sumatra Island, Indonesia. Diversity, 14(6): 420.

Ladkood, D., and Kullachai, P. 2018. Pattern of farmer in elephant affected area, village No.7, Ban Aang Sue Dam, Tha Takiap sub-district, Tha Takiap district, Chachoengsao. Proceedings of 56th Kasetsart University Annual Conference: Plants, Animals, Veterinary Medicine, Agricultural Extension and Home Economics.

Linh, N. T., and Tuyet, P. T. 2019. Assessment the human-elephant conflict in Dong Nai Biosphere Reserve and propose management. Retrieved 2024,

Maifaey, V., and Arsanok, L. 2018. Potential of land use change for human-elephant conflict mitigation in Kaeng Krachan National Park. Journal of Community Development and Well Beings, 63–86.

Menon, V., and Tiwari, S. KR. 2019. Population status of Asian elephants Elephas maximus and key threats. International Zoo Yearbook, 53(1): 17–30.

Mohd-Radzi, N. H., Karuppannan, K. V., Abdullah-Fauzi, N. A., Mohd-Ridwan, A. R., Othman, N., Muhammad Abu Bakar, A.-L., Gani, M., Abdul-Razak, M. F., and Md-Zain, B. M. 2022. Determining the diet of wild Asian elephants (Elephas maximus) at human–elephant conflict areas in Peninsular Malaysia using DNA metabarcoding. Biodiversity Data Journal, 10.

Mutinda, M., Chenge, G., Gakuya, F., Otiende, M., Omondi, P., Kasiki, S., Soriguer, R. C., and Alasaad, S. 2014. Detusking fence-breaker elephants as an approach in human-elephant conflict mitigation. PLoS ONE, 9(3).

Naha, D., Sathyakumar, S., Dash, S., Chettri, A., and Rawat, G.S. 2019 Assessment and prediction of spatial patterns of human-elephant conflicts in changing land cover scenarios of a human dominated landscape in North Bengal. PLoS ONE, 14(2).

Nelson, A., Bidwell, P., and Sillero-Zubiri, C. 2003. A review of humane elephant conflict management strategies. People and Wildlife Initiative. Wildlife Conservation Research Unit, Oxford University. www.peopleandwildlife.org.uk/crmanuals/HumanElephantConflictP&WManual

Nguyen, V. V., Phan, T. T., and Chun-Hung, L. 2022. Integrating multiple aspects of human–elephant conflict management in Dong Nai Biosphere Reserve, Vietnam. Global Ecology and Conservation, 39. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.gecco.2022.e02285

Nguyen, V. V., Phan, T. T., Ferdin, A. E., and Lee, C.-H. 2021. Conducting importance–performance analysis for human–elephant conflict management surrounding a national park in Vietnam. Forests, 12(11): 1458.

Nyhus, P. J., Tilson, R., and Sumianto. 2000. Crop-raiding elephants and conservation implications at way Kambas National Park, Sumatra, Indonesia. Oryx, 34(04): 262.

Oelrichs, C. M.-C., Lloyd, D. J., and Christidis, L. 2016. Strategies for mitigating forest arson and Elephant Conflict in way Kambas National Park, Sumatra, Indonesia. Tropical Conservation Science, 9(2): 565–583.

Perera, B. M. A. O. 2009. The human-elephant conflict: A review of current status and mitigation methods. Gajah, 30: 41-52.

Redpath, S. M., Young, J., Evely, A., Adams, W. M., Sutherland, W. J., Whitehouse, A., Amar, A., Lambert, R. A., Linnell, J. D. C., Watt, A., and Gutiérrez, R. J. 2013. Understanding and managing conservation conflicts. Trends in Ecology & Evolution, 28(2): 100–109.

Rubino, E. C., Serenari, C., Othman, N., Ancrenaz, M., Sarjono, F., and Ahmad, E. 2020. Viewing Bornean human–elephant conflicts through an environmental justice lens. Human–Wildlife Interactions, 14(3): 487–504.

Safriansyah, R., and Baabud, S. F. 2022. An update on human-elephant conflict in Aceh, Indonesia. https://issuu.com/anggasafik/docs/an_update_on_human_elephant_conflict_in_aceh_indo.

Sampson, C., Leimgruber, P., Rodriguez, S., McEvoy, J., Sotherden, E., and Tonkyn, D. 2019. Perception of human–elephant conflict and conservation attitudes of affected communities in Myanmar. Tropical Conservation Science, 12.

Sampson, C., Rodriguez, S. L., Leimgruber, P., Huang, Q., and Tonkyn, D. 2021. A quantitative assessment of the indirect impacts of human-elephant conflict. PLoS one, 16(7).

Sapkota, S., Aryal, A., Baral, S. R., Hayward, M. W., and Raubenheimer, D. 2014. Economic analysis of electric fencing for mitigating human-wildlife conflict in Nepal. Journal of Resources and Ecology, 5(3): 237–243.

Scheijen, C. P. J., Richards, S. A., Smit, J., Jones, T., and Nowak, K. 2018. Efficacy of beehive fences as barriers to African elephants: A case study in Tanzania. Oryx, 53(1): 92–99.

Shaffer, L.J., Khadka, K., K., Van Den Hoek, J., and Naithani. K., J. 2019. Human-Elephant Conflict: A Review of Current Management Strategies and Future Directions. Front. Ecol. Evol, 6:235.

Scheijen, C. P. J., Richards, S. A., Smit, J., Jones, T., and Nowak, K. 2019. Efficacy of beehive fences as barriers to African elephants: a case study in Tanzania. Oryx, 53(1): 92–99.

Sinha, S. (2021). Visible and hidden costs of human-elephant conflict on smallholders in Peninsular Malaysia. School of Environmental & Geographical Sciences. University of Nottingham, Malaysia Campus. 109 pp.

Slotow, R., A., Blackmore, M., Henley, K., Trendler, and M. Garaï. 2021. Could Culling of Elephants Be Considered Inhumane and Illegal in South African Law? Journal of International Wildlife Law & Policy 24(3–4):1–26.

Sugiyo, S., Ardiantiono, A., Santo, A., Marthy, W., and Amama, F. 2016. Evaluating the intervention methods to reduce human-elephant conflict around Way Kambas National Park. International Wildlife Symposium, 35(6).

Thai PBS. 2019. ครม.เห็นชอบจ่ายเงินชดเชยภัยช้างป่าบุกพื้นที่เกษตร. Thai PBS. Retrieved 2024, available from https://www.thaipbs.or.th/news/ content/277853.

Thant, Z. M., Leimgruber, P., Williams, A. C., Oo, Z. M., Røskaft, E., and May, R. 2023. Factors influencing the habitat suitability of wild Asian elephants and their implications for Human–Elephant Conflict in Myanmar. Global Ecology and Conservation, 43.

Thant, Z. M., May, R., and Røskaft, E. 2021. Pattern and distribution of human-elephant conflicts in three conflict-prone landscapes in Myanmar. Global Ecology and Conservation, 25.

Thekaekara, T., Bhagwat, S. A., and Thornton, T. F. 2021. Coexistence and culture: Understanding human diversity and tolerance in human-elephant interactions. Frontiers in Conservation Science, 2.

Thuy Linh, P., and Thi Tuyet, P. 2019 Assessment the Human-Elephant Conflict in Dong Nai Biosphere Reserve and Propose Management Solutions. The Rufford Foundation and Center for Nature Conservation and Development (CCD): Ha Noi, Vietnam.

van de Water A, and Matteson, K. 2018. Human-elephant conflict in western Thailand: Socio-economic drivers and potential mitigation strategies. PLoS ONE, 13(6).

van de Water, A., King, L. E., Arkajak, R., Arkajak, J., van Doormaal, N., Ceccarelli, V., Sluiter, L., Doornwaard, S. M., Praet, V., Owen, D., and Matteson, K. 2020. Beehive fences as a sustainable local solution to human‐elephant conflict in Thailand. Conservation Science and Practice, 2(10).

Von Hagen, L. Corde, S., Norris, P., Kasaine, S., Githiru, M., Amakobe, B., Mutwiwa, U., and Schulte, B. 2023. Chemical Ecology and Elephant Conservation: Examining Chili Pepper Deterrent Fences. Chemical Signals in Vertebrates 15.

Webber, C., Sereivathana, T., Maltby, M., and Lee, P. 2011. Elephant crop-raiding and human–elephant conflict in Cambodia: Crop selection and seasonal timings of raids. Oryx, 45(2): 243-251.

Wettasin, M., Chaiyarat, R., Youngpoy, N., Jieychien, N., Sukmasuang, R., and Tanhan, P. 2023. Environmental factors induced crop raiding by wild Asian elephant (Elephas Maximus) in the Eastern Economic Corridor, Thailand. Scientific Reports, 13(1): 13388.

Wilson, G., Gray, R. J., Radinal, R., Hasanuddin, H., Azmi, W., Sayuti, A., Muhammad, H., Abdullah, A., Nazamuddin, B. S., Sofyan, H., Riddle, H. S., Stremme, C., and Desai, A. A. (2021). Between a rock and a hard place: Rugged terrain features and human disturbance affect behaviour and habitat use of Sumatran elephants in Aceh, Sumatra, Indonesia. Biodiversity and Conservation, 30(3): 597–618.

Wong, E. P., Campos-Arceiz, A., Zulaikha, N., Chackrapani, P., Quilter, A. G., de la Torre, J. A., Solana-Mena, A., Tan, W. H., Ong, L., Rusli, M. A., Sinha, S., Ponnusamy, V., Lim, T. W., Or, O. C., Aziz, A. F., Hii, N., Tan, A. S., Wadey, J., Loke, V. P., Zawawi, A., Idris, M. M., Abdul, P. P., Abdul, R. M. T., and Saaban, S. 2021. Living with elephants: Evidence-based planning to conserve wild elephants in a megadiverse South East Asian country. Frontiers in Conservation Science, 2.

Zaini, A. A., Noor, M. I. M., Ahmad, B. E., Mustafa, A. M. A., and Eylen, W. V. 2023. Economic Valuation of Forest as Habitat for Elephants: Case Study at Belum-Temenggor Forest Complex. Bioresources and Environment, 1(2): 34-48.